Sicilian & Italian catering · Willoughby, Ohio · Eastlake, Willoughby Hills, Wickliffe
Catering in Willoughby your guests will talk about for years
Willoughby is next door to our kitchen: halls, offices, downtown venues and backyards. Hot, on time, and exactly what we agreed, or you don't pay for it.
Get a Catering Quote



Three ways we do it in Willoughby
Family Style
From 100 guests
- Courses served at the table
- Three entrees, every premium dish
- Porcelain plates, bowls and silverware
- Double the staff, one point person
Served Buffet (most popular)
From $3,000 · 50+ guests
- Servers on the buffet up to 3 hours
- Stainless chafers and serving ware
- Premium dishes, food kept hot and full
- Leftovers packed in your fridge. We clean up.
Hot Drop-Off
From $850 · 25+ guests
- Delivered hot in covered pans, ready to serve
- Nothing to return
- Core menu: cutlets, meatballs, pasta, potatoes, green beans, salad
- Bread and 3 sauces included
Every dinner: pick 2 entrees, 2 sides and 1 salad. House ciabatta and three sauces included. One all-in price. No service charge, no delivery fee, no hidden fees. See the full catering menu.
Why we're different
- Extra virgin olive oil only. No seed oils.
- Made from scratch, even the bread and sauces.
- Nothing from a can but the tomatoes.
- Local and seasonal produce.
- Gluten-free cutlets and meatballs.
- Chicken raised without antibiotics.
- No dyes, fillers, preservatives or refined sugar.
What hosts say
Dylan & his team did a fantastic job catering my 150ppl wedding. From the bread bar, grazing table board, and one big customized Italian dinner - everyone raved about the food! His team took care of my guests making sure everyone was truly comfortable. From setup to tear down not one issue.
MarissaWedding, 150 guests · Verified Google reviewDylan did the catering for our wedding rehearsal dinner and I could not be more grateful for the work he did! Our family is Lebanese and everyone at our rehearsal was blown away by the quality of the food we had. People were going back for seconds and thirds!
PaytonWedding rehearsal dinner · Verified Google reviewThis is the first time that our church has used Cast Iron kitchen. They were on time with our food, it came hot, and they set everything up for us. And it was so delicious! Some people were surprised that the chicken and potatoes were gluten-free, It tasted that good! And oh my gosh, the homemade bread they make from scratch, it was to die for.
JimChurch dinner · Verified Google reviewWe have used Cast Iron Kitchen's catering service several times now for our company functions. It is always a hit and everyone loves it! Very happy with the wonderful food and excellent customer service that Dylan provides!
GinaCompany events · Verified Google reviewCouldn't be happier with the catering service… The food (buffet for 120 people…) was wonderful… I'd recommend Cast Iron Catering to anybody looking for a caterer for any small, medium or large event. Very friendly, great service, GREAT FOOD!
RobertCelebration of life, 120 guests · Verified Google reviewCast Iron Kitchen did a fantastic job providing a traditional Thanksgiving Dinner for the Pediatric Cancer inpatient unit at Rainbow Babies and Children’s Hospital… We heard great feedback about the meal from the patients and their families. They said it was like a home cooked meal and not mass produced.
JenniferHospital Thanksgiving dinner · Verified Google reviewGet your quote
About 3 minutes. We call you with one all-in price.
Hot, on time, and exactly what we agreed, or you don't pay for it.
Rather talk? Call or text (440) 321-8677.